New York Supreme Court April 3, 1968 (People v. Marino)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-04-1968
Mitchell D. Schweitzer, J.
The defendant pleaded guilty to the crimes of unlawful entry and petit larceny on June 1, 1967. He was sentenced on October 16,1967, for unlawful entry, to the penitentiary of the City of New York under former article 7-A of the Correction Law (§§ 200-208). Sentence was suspended on the petit larceny count.
He now applies to be resentenced on the ground that the sentence imposed was illegal. He alleges that inasmuch as the former article 7-A — Parole System in Certain Cities (Correction Law, § 200 et seq.) —was repealed by section 6 of chapter 324 of the Laws of 1967, effective September 1,1967, there no longer *520was any New York City Parole Commission in existence at the time sentence was imposed and hence the sentence was invalid.
Former article 7-A of the Correction Law was repealed by legislation designed to “ accommodate the correction law to the revised penal law, ’ ’ which was to take effect on the date the repeal became effective (see note appended to chapter 324). The question in this case is whether subdivision 3 of section 5.05 of the new Penal Law (enacted by L. 1965, ch. 1030, eff. Sept. 1, 1967), that provides for continued application of the former Penal Law to sentences imposed for offenses committed prior to September 1, 1967, also applies to the imposition of sentence under article 7-A.
Subdivision 3 of section 5.05 of the new Penal Law states that crimes committed prior to the effective date of that law — as in the instant case — must be “construed and punished” in the same manner as if the new Penal Law had not been enacted. Since section 500.05 of the new Penal Law repeals the old Penal Law as of the commencement date of the new, an exception to the repeal was needed to cover offenses committed prior to September 1, 1967. The exception is provided by subdivision 3 of section 5.05. The obvious intent of this provision is twofold.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit