New York Supreme Court January 29, 1968 (Manno v. Berman)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-01-1968
Daniel E. Fitzpatrick, J.
This is an article 78 proceeding to review and annul respondent’s determination denying landlord petitioners’ protest and affirming an order of the District Rent Director dated May 22, 1967 which modified a prior order decontrolling the .first floor right apartment of the premises 1734 Harman Street, Queens, owned by petitioners.
Prior to the occupancy of the present tenant Joseph Roth, the subject apartment had been occupied by petitioners’ predecessor in title for a period of five years. Petitioners, upon taking title to the premises, applied for statutory decontrol of the apartment based upon the prior owner’s occupancy. On August 23, 1965, the apartment was decontrolled.
The report of the local rent inspector reveals that at the time the application for decontrol was being investigated, Joseph Roth was occupying the subject apartment. In fact, the tenant’s occupancy was under a two-year lease at a rental of $60 per month. Although the tenant was given notice of the proceeding for statutory decontrol, he made no.protest.
Apparently upon learning that at the expiration of the lease the landlords intended to raise the rent to $90 per month, the tenant, in April, 1967, brought to the attention of the District Rent Director the fact that he had occupied a controlled apartment in the building prior to taking occupancy of the subject apartment and that he had exchanged apartments at the landlords’ demand and for their convenience. The District Director then reopened the original proceedings and, as a result, the decontrol order was modified by providing that the apartment was to remain subject to control at a maximum rent of $60 per month co-extensive with the tenant’s occupancy. Petitioners filed a protest, asserting that the District Director had no jurisdiction to modify the earlier order. However, upon a de novo review of the record, the protest was denied.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit