New York County Courts September 4, 1968 (Town of Starkey v. Hill)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-09-1968

Lyman H. Smith, J.

Defendant-appellant appeals from a judgment of a Court of Special Sessions, the Hon. M. Lyman Pierce, Town Justice of the Town of Starkey, presiding, under which the said defendant has been found guilty after a trial without a jury on July 11, 1968, of a violation of the town’s “ junk yard ” ordinance, designated as Local Law No. 1-1966. Upon conviction the court imposed a fine of $25 and directed that the defendant comply with the said local law within 30 days.

The defendant-appellant in his affidavit of errors contends, inter alia, ‘‘ that the record is wholly devoid of proof of any violation * * * in that there was no proof that any or all of the vehicles specified in the charge were no longer intended or in condition for legal use on the public highways ”. The record seems to bear out appellant’s contention.

The testimony of the Town Supervisor and Town Constable, the only witnesses called for the prosecution, did establish that there were “ 2 cars, 1 bus and 2 stock cars ” present on the defendant’s premises on two or more dates during May and July of 1968. The testimony of these witnesses paraphrased the information charging the violation and little more, other than to note that the vehicles were “ unregistered ”, apparently referring to the absence of license plates, and that none of these vehicles carried “ inspection stickers ”. The transcript failed to reveal any helpful testimony as to either the actual operating condition of the observed vehicles, or any facts from *720which the intention of the owner of the premises could be inferred or determined.

The town’s Local Law No. 1-1966 prohibits any person from operating, establishing or maintaining a “junk yard” unless he has obtained a license to operate a junk yard business and has obtained a certificate of approval of the location of such a junk yard.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.