New York County Courts September 10, 1968 (People v. Kneller)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1968

William F. Christiana, J.

Defendant appeals from a judgment of conviction rendered in the Court of Special Sessions of the Town of Grhent on February 8, 1968, convicting him of a violation of section 600 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law, commonly designated as ‘1 leaving the scene of accident ’ ’. He was fined $50.

At the opening of the trial, defendant’s counsel moved to dismiss the information, and renewed his motion at appropriate times thereafter, on the ground that the same was legally insufficient. The court denied the motions and such denials constitute one of the specifications of error on this appeal.

The body of the information, which concededly was inartistically drawn, alleges: 1 ‘ Defendant did operate his motor vehicle and did leave the place where damage occurred to the property of another, to wit: Stanley Novine, L. Dens, State of New York and knowing that damage had been caused due to his accident, which damage consisted of: one cement guide post and one caution sign knocked down belonging to the State of New York,. 65 feet of wood fence belonging to L. Deus (summer home) knocked down and a mail box the property of Stanley Novine damaged.”

Section 600 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law mandates that an operator of a motor vehicle causing damage to property shall stop and give specified information to the party sustaining the damage, or to a police officer, or if these are unavailable, then to report the accident as soon as physical ability will permit to the nearest police station or judicial officer.

It is to be observed that the information contains no allegation that defendant failed to report the accident by ,any of the methods required by the statute. Especially to be noted is that section 600 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law, defining the crime, is entitled “Leaving scene of accident without reporting ”. (Emphasis supplied.)

The judgment of conviction must be reversed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.