Arizona Supreme Court October 24, 1968, No. 8488 (Nagel v. Field Services, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-10-1968
McFARLAND, Chief Justice:
This is an action to establish a constructive trust. Plaintiff-appellant Shirley Feinstein Nagel, hereinafter referred to as Nagel, owned an undivided one-third of a piece of real property located at the Southwest corner of Central Avenue and Maryland in Phoenix, Arizona. Another one-third was owned by David Tasky, and the remaining one-third by Arthur Petersen. These three parties obtained a mortgage commitment for $125,000 on the land and upon a twelve-unit apartment building to be constructed on it. They also obtained interim financing, and proceeded to build the apartments.
By February 15, 1960 the bills which had been paid, plus those due and owing, exceeded the $125,000 available by more than $50,000. Creditors were exerting pressure, mechanics’ liens were imminent, and the situation was critical. Nagel had invested over $30,000; it does not appear in the *494record how much the other two co-owners had in the project.
Nagel contacted Robert Pinder, an old friend in whom she had complete confidence, and he promised to help her out of her difficulties. First, however, he explained that it was necessary to transfer the title to Field Services, Inc., a corporation which he controlled, and in which he owned a majority of the stock. Tasky and Petersen decided to accept their losses. One conveyed to Field Services for $10,-000; the other, for $5,000. Nagel, however, preferred to stay with the project in the hopes that Pinder’s money and know-how would reduce her loss and perhaps even turn it into a profit. She conveyed her one-third interest to Field Services upon Pinder’s oral promise (to use the words of his answer) to “execute a trust agreement evidencing, among other things, the interest of • plaintiff.” Her deed to Field Services was dated April 12, 1960, and was recorded a day or two later.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit