Alabama Court of Appeals October 8, 1968, 4 Div. 656 (Carroll v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-1968

CATES, Judge.

This appeal was originally assigned to Johnson, J. The case was reassigned to the writer on the disagreement of the writer and Price, P. J., with the opinion filed by Judge Johnson.

The facts in the record are quite simple. Carroll and another man were in a truck which drove up to a still in Covington County. They unloaded a large amount *81of grain and sugar at the still yard, cranked up a gasoline motor which ran a pump to supply cooling water for the flake stand and engaged in other activities in and about the apparatus.

The State adduced testimony that the still was a complete one. Carroll testified he had gone into the area to get pears.

The jury found Carroll guilty under Count 2 which charged possession of a still. Upon this verdict, the judge pronounced judgment and sentence.

Further facts are contained in the opinion filed by Johnson, J., infra.

We have considered the entire record under Code 1940, T. 15, § 389, including the following:

a) The clerk’s certificate;

b) The court reporter’s certificate;

c) The statement of the organization of the court; '

d) The indictment (caption, charge, conclusions, and required endorsements);

e) Judgment entry (arraignment, presence of counsel, empanelling of jury, verdict, adjudication of guilt, allocutus, sentence and notice of appeal) ;

f) Proceedings on the motion for new trial; and

g) Each ruling of the trial judge adverse to the appellant.

The matter on which our colleague would posit a reversal, we believe, was, first, harmless; second, covered by waiver; and, third, of doubtful inclusion in the scope of trial.

A somewhat similar matter was considered in Haynes v. State, 40 Ala.App. 106, 109 So.2d 738. The majority considers that Carroll voluntarily absented himself from the courtroom and, therefore, waived his right to be present.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.