Court of Appeals of North Carolina September 18, 1968, No. 68SC165 (Edens v. Foulks)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-09-1968

MosRis, J.

The only question presented by plaintiff’s appeal is whether her interest in the land is a contingent remainder or a vested remainder.

The record is completely devoid of any information as to whether Albert L. Duggins is living. Since the complaint is silent as to this, and the question here presented would be moot if he were deceased, we assume that he is living.

If plaintiff’s interest is a contingent remainder, she has no standing to maintain an action for waste and forfeiture under G.S. 1-533. The rule was clearly enunciated by Taylor, C.J., speaking for the Court in Browne v. Blick, 7 N.C. 511, 519: “No one shall have an action of waste unless he hath the immediate estate of inheritance.” See Latham v. Lumber Co., 139 N.C. 9, 51 S.E. 780. The sound reason for the rule was discussed in Richardson v. Richardson, 152 N.C. 705, 68 S.E. 217, where the action was for waste and forfeiture. The Court held that the action could not be maintained by *328plaintiff a contingent remainderman because if allowed, “The life estate is destroyed by the forfeiture resulting from the waste under the statute, and yet the event upon which the plaintiff is to take his estate in remainder has not happened.”

The general rule set out in 56 Am. Jur., Waste § 13, p. 459, was quoted with approval in Strickland v. Jackson, 261 N.C. 360, 361, 134 S.E. 2d 661:

“It is well settled that one entitled to a contingent remainder cannot maintain an action at. law against the tenant in possession to recover damages for waste, for the reason that it cannot be known in advance of the happening of the contingency whether the contingent remainderman would suffer damage or loss by the waste; and if the estate never became vested in him, he would be paid for that which he had not lost.”

Plaintiff contends that she has a vested remainder in the lands described in the complaint and, therefore, the complaint is sufficient to withstand demurrer. We do not agree.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.