Court of Customs and Patent Appeals November 27, 1968, No. 8030 (In re DuPuis)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-11-1968

Wokley, Chief Judge,

delivered the opinion of the court:

The issue here is whether the Board of Appeals committed reversible error in affirming the examiner’s rejection of claims 1-41 as unpatentable over Kursh2 in view of Toellner3 and Beinsberg4 under 35 USC 103.

The invention relates to hair protectors for use by women when applying cosmetics to the face and neck. The specification describes the state of the prior art:

Although hair bands or protectors have been proposed heretofore for ithe same general purpose, they were objectionable for one reason or another. Primarily, prior protectors required moving the arms behind the head when the user applied the protector and such prior devices were not readily adjustable to the hair line of the forehead and the back of the neck. Moreover, such prior protectors were tied by means of tapes at their ends or had fasteners at the' back of the head which were difficult to engage. Additionally, fasteners at the back included projections of one kind or another which were objectionable because they could not be seen by the user.

Appellant’s solution to those problems is a band having (1) an elastic secured centrally of its lower edge to provide a gathering or pocket for receiving the hair at the back of the neck, and (2) a fastener at its *735ends to permit the wearer to secure the ends at the forehead, as reflected in claims 1 and 2:

1. A hair protector comprising an elongate band having a longitudinal upper edge and a longitudinal lower edge, an elastic secured to said lower edge between the ends thereof and only along the center portion thereof, said band being gathered where it is secured' to said elastic to provide a hair receiving pocket, and a fastener on the ends of said band.

2. A hair protector as defined in claim 1 wherein said fastener is comprised of flexible patches having interengageable mating surfaces.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.