Indiana Court of Appeals March 20, 1968, No. 20,562 (Indiana Shovel & Supply Co. v. Castillo)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-03-1968

Faulconer, J.

— The appellee filed a complaint against the appellant in two paragraphs, the first for specific performance of a written contract, and the second in replevin and damages. Appellant filed a demurrer attacking each paragraph of plain*370tiff’s complaint on the grounds that the complaint does not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. The court overruled the demurrer and appellant filed its answer to each paragraph of the complaint in admission and denial. In addition, the answer to Paragraph I states, “that plaintiff has not performed his contract as provided in Exhibit ‘A’ to Plaintiff’s Complaint, has defaulted on the same and is not now in a contractual position of performing his agreement, more than three (3) years having elapsed since the time plaintiff agreed in his said contract to complete performance.” In addition to its denial to Paragraph II, appellant also states that “plaintiff is not the owner of the equipment sought nor entitled to its possession.”

At the close of plaintiff-appellee’s evidence, in a trial to the court, appellant’s motion for a finding in its favor was overruled. Appellant rested without submitting evidence and renewed its motion for a finding in its favor, which again was overruled.

The trial court made its finding for the plaintiff-appellee and entered judgment that “the agreement sued upon in plaintiff’s complaint shall be fully performed and executed, that the defendant is ordered to surrender and deliver to the plaintiff possession and legal title to the property described in plaintiff’s complaint, . . . and it is further ordered, . . . that the Clerk of this Court, upon the defendant showing of a receipt by the plaintiff of the aforesaid property, pay over to the defendant the sum of Five Hundred Sixty-Five Dollars ($565.00) which has been tendered to the Clerk of this Court by plaintiff.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.