Indiana Court of Appeals September 23, 1968, No. 378A20 (Barkey v. Schermerhorn)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-09-1968

Bierly, J.

The original appeal in this cause was dismissed by this court on September 23, 1968. See (1968) 143 Ind. App. 310, 240 N. E. 2d 93, 15 Ind. Dec. 350.

On October 8, 1968, the appellants filed their Petition for Reinstatement of Appeal and for Rehearing. Said petition contains a lengthy argument, discussion and citation to authorities and to the respective briefs of the parties. On October 14, 1968, appellees filed “Appellees’ Answer to Appellants’ Petition for Reinstatement of Appeal and for Rehearing”. While we do not consider the petition to be sufficient to warrant our approval, yet we shall comment briefly on its form.

Rule 2-22 of our Supreme Court reads:

“. . . REHEARING. Application for a rehearing of any cause shall be made by petition, separate from the briefs, signed by counsel, and filed with the clerk within twenty (20) days from rendition of the decision, stating concisely the reasons why the decision is thought tobe erroneous. Such application may, if desired, be supported by briefs, but such briefs will not be received after the time allowed for filing the petition. Parties opposing the rehearing may file briefs within ten (10) days after the filing of the petition. Adopted April 17,1940. Effective September 2, 1940. Amended June 17, 1943. Effective September 6, 1943.” (Emphasis supplied.)

This court has held repeatedly that the incorporation of a supporting brief in a. petition for- rehearing, is a sufficient ground for dismissing the petition for failure to conform with Rule 2-22, supra.

In McClain’s Estate v. McClain (1962), 133 Ind. App. 645, 184 N. E. 2d 281, Judge Áx, . in deciding this question, quoted an earlier opinion written by Judge Achor of the Supreme Court of Indiana; in Automobile Underwriters, Inc. v. Smith (1961), 241 Ind. 302, 171 N. E. 2d 823, wherein he said: ’ .. ' ■ ......

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.