Louisiana Court of Appeal February 5, 1968, No. 2902 (Sitzman v. Fidelity General Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-1968

TUCKER, Judge.

Plaintiff, Leonard J. Sitzman, was awarded $4,018.66 under a contract of indemnity with defendant-insurer to compensate him for losses incurred as the result of the burglary of Sitzman’s Department Store on September 8, 1964. Defendant appealed from this judgment and plaintiff answered the appeal asking for an increase in the award for loss of merchandise and also for penalties and attorney’s fees, which were denied by the trial court.

. Defendant appeals on two grounds: (1) that plaintiff either does not have any insurable interest in the store or that he has only a partial one and (2) plaintiff did not keep sufficient records to arrive at an accurate amount of the loss.

With regard to the first contention, i. e., the lack of insurable interest, the insurance policy contains the following provision:

“Ownership of Property; Interests Covered: The insured property may be owned by the insured, or held by the insured in any capacity whether or not the insured is liable for the loss thereof, or may be property as respects which the insured is legally liable; provided, the insurance applies only to the interest of the insured in such property, including the insured’s liability to others, and does not apply to the interest of any other person or organization in any of said property unless included in the insured’s proof of loss.” (Emphasis added.)

Defendant points out that Norvin Sitzman, son of the plaintiff, was identified by the investigating officer as the victim of the burglary rather than his father, the plaintiff-insured. The police officer also testified Norvin Sitzman stated that he was “one of the owners.” Defendant also relies on the testimony of Mrs. Sitzman who testified the plaintiff, her ex-husband, owned the store jointly with their two sons, although she did not know the percentage of interest each one had.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.