Supreme Court of Florida March 13, 1968, No. 36528 (Robinette v. E. R. Jahna Industries, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-03-1968
THORNAL, Justice.
We have for review an order of the Florida Industrial Commission which reversed a workmen’s compensation order entered by a deputy commissioner.
We must again decide whether a compensation award should be apportioned.
Petitioner, Robinette, a 49 year old laborer with a sixth grade education, suffered a compensable injury while in the employ of respondent, Jahna, on July 29, 1963. He was hospitalized for three weeks and did not return to work for two months. While on the job, he reinjured his back on April 20, 1964. It was then determined that he had three ruptured discs. Surgery was considered inadvisable. A claim for compensation benefits was filed. After a hearing was held on December 7, 1965, the Deputy Commissioner found that claimant was totally and permanently disabled. He found that, following the first accident claimant suffered a physical impairment which was known to the employer and that this condition merged with the subsequent disability from the second accident to produce total disability. An examining physician reported that claimant *105had suffered a multiple level discogenic disease which came on while performing work which he had previously performed many times without difficulty. He stated that although the claimant “has never had previous difficulty with his back” it was simply “a matter of what particular incident would initiate his clinical syndrome”. He then found that the initiating factors were the two work-connected injuries. The Deputy, therefore, found that the back condition was asymptomatic prior to the first accident and that the ensuing disability was attributable to the back strain and was not significantly necessitated by the pre-existing condition. As previously stated, he then found a merger of the physical impairment resulting from the first and second injuries.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit