District Court of Appeal of Florida August 15, 1968, No. J-257 (Copeland v. West American Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1968

RAWLS, Judge.

We are here concerned with the theft coverage of a casualty automobile insurance policy. Summary final judgment was entered by the trial judge in favor of Appellee insurance company, hence this appeal. Appellant’s points on appeal amount to one question: Did the trial judge err in entering a summary judgment upon the evi-dentiary material submitted? We conclude that he did; material issues of fact have been controverted, and, therefore, we reverse.

Appellant Copeland, who lived in Orlando, in 1961 purchased a 1961 Pontiac automobile and financed the major portion of the purchase price through Appellant, Bell Bakeries Credit Union. A policy of insurance was secured from West American Insurance Company. In May of 1962, Copeland thought “ * * * he was a little tight * * * wasn’t in too good straights * * was going to have to let it [the car] go * * * ” and so he made a deal with a Mr. Mobley of Jacksonville to take the car with the understanding that he would get it financed. Mobley in turn delivered to him possession of a 1951 Plymouth. The deal was consummated with Mobley garaging the Pontiac in Jacksonville. Subsequently Mobley’s brother-in-law stole the Pontiac, which was finally located in Texas. The car was damaged as a result of the theft. A claim made upon the insurance company was rejected upon the grounds that the policy provision, “ * * * Assignment of interest under this policy shall not bind the company until its consent is endorsed thereon * * * ”, had been violated.

Copeland and Mobley’s agreement forms the basis for the finding that a controverted material fact exists. Copeland’s payments to the credit union were deducted weekly from his salary in the sum of $28.50. The credit union would not accept Mobley in lieu of Copeland since he was not a member. Copeland agreed to continue making the payments on the Pontiac until Mobley could arrange refinancing. Mobley in turn agreed to pay Copeland $20.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.