District Court of Appeal of Florida June 27, 1968, No. 1449 (Ferguson v. Goodley)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1968

PATTERSON, WILLIAM A., Associate Judge.

This appeal is taken from an order quashing a rule nisi and denying the relief sought by the appellants as against appel-lee, Midland National Insurance Company.

The facts are that Henry E. Ferguson and Learnte U. Ferguson, the appellants herein and the plaintiffs below, obtained a judgment against Patricia Melinda Goodley and Bruce Lewis as a result of a jury verdict in the Circuit Court for Broward County, Florida.

*496Plaintiffs caused execution to be issued against Goodley and Lewis and the writs were returned unsatisfied. Subsequent to this, plaintiffs filed their petition in the circuit court for supplementary proceedings, joinder, and rule nisi. As a result of this petition, a rule nisi was entered against appellee, Midland National Insurance Company, commanding the company to pay plaintiffs’ judgment which they had secured against defendants, Goodley and Lewis, or to appear and show cause why judgment should not be entered against it.

Appellee, Midland National Insurance Company, filed a motion to quash the rule nisi upon the following grounds:

“1. Plaintiffs’ attempt to join MIDLAND NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY is contrary to the provisions of the laws of this State and is entirely improper.

“2. As argued at length at the prior proceedings, other remedies are available to Plaintiffs by Statute and not available under these circumstances as MIDLAND NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY was never the liability carrier for the Defendant, BRUCE LEWIS, and is not subject to the supplementary proceedings sought.

“3. MIDLAND NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY did not defend BRUCE LEWIS under a ‘reservation or right’, and further relies on the affidavit filed previously in this cause by Hugh Wood, Esquire, dated December 19, 1966.”

The material parts of the affidavit of Hugh Wood, Esquire, referred to in this motion are as follows :

“1. He is and was the attorney for Midland National Insurance Company and in these proceedings.

“2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.