District Court of Appeal of Florida August 20, 1968, No. 68-55 (Carter v. Dade County)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-08-1968

HENDRY, Judge.

This is an appeal by the counterplaintiff, Theo Carter, d/b/a Natural Fish Mount Company, from an adverse summary final judgment.

This law suit arose out of a dispute concerning an agreement entered into between Dade County and Carter, whereby Carter was granted the right to operate a taxidermy agency at Haulover Beach Park Marina. Paragraph 22 of the subject agreement states:

“This license conveys to the licensee the exclusive right to solicit and transport from the park fish mounts, but is not to be construed in any way as to limit the rights of park patrons in transporting their fish to a taxidermist of their own choice.”

Dade County initiated the cause, claiming default by Carter in the payment of sums due under the contract. Carter denied the indebtedness and counter-claimed for damages upon the ground that the county had not granted her “the exclusive right to solicit and transport from the park fish mounts”, but had instead allowed a competitor the right to solicit and transport fish mounts from the park in direct contravention of the agreement.

The county denied the allegations of the counter-claim and moved for summary judgment, which motion was denied upon first hearing. However, upon rehearing, the lower court entered an order reading in part as follows:

“ * * * It is the Court’s conclusion that in the License Agreement sued upon DADE COUNTY granted to the Coun-terplaintiff, THEO CARTER, d/b/a NATURAL FISH MOUNT COMPANY, an exclusive license to operate a taxidermy agency within the Haulover Beach Park Marina for the period of the License Agreement. By granting such exclusive license, DADE COUNTY granted to Counterplaintiff a license to operate a taxidermy agency within the Haulover Beach Park Marina for the period of the License Agreement and agreed not to grant any other person, corporation or entity a license, permit or right to operate a taxidermy agency within the Haulover Beach Park Marina during period of the License Agreement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.