Louisiana Court of Appeal July 1, 1968, No. 11064 (Wilson v. Phoenix of Hartford Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1968
AYRES, Judge.
This is an action for damages for personal injuries, pain, and suffering sustained by plaintiff in and resulting from a motor vehicle collision, and for incidental medical expenses and loss of wages. Before trial, liability was conceded by defendants and only a question of the amount of damages was at issue in a trial before a jury which rendered a verdict in plaintiff’s favor for $10,000.00. In overruling a motion for a new trial, the trial judge declined to suggest a remittitur although of the opinion that a verdict for $5,000.00 would have been adequate to compensate plaintiff for the damages sustained.
Therefore, the question on appeal by defendants relates to the quantum of the award and concerns the abuse of the “much discretion” vested in a jury or trial judge.
On an appeal where the quantum of an award of damages is at issue, all the facts and circumstances on which the trial court based the award should be reviewed to determine (1) whether there has been an abuse of the “much discretion” vested in the trial court in assessing damages, and (2) if, after a review of all the facts and circumstances an abuse of discretion is found, the amount of the award should be modified as the case warrants. Ballard v. National Indemnity Company of Omaha, Neb., 246 La. 963, 169 So.2d 64 (1964). The facts and circumstances of this case will be reviewed in accordance with this rule.
Plaintiff’s special damages, with the exception of his claim for loss of wages, were stipulated as follows:
Hospital and doctors’ bills $ 87.80
Drugs and medications 7.70
Ambulance bill 20.00
Damage to automobile (deductible amount for insurance coverage) 100.00
$215.50
Plaintiff sustained a loss of wages as shown by the testimony of the comptroller of plaintiff’s employer, Newspaper Production Company, in the amount of $188.06. The aggregate of the special damages is therefore $403.56. By a deduction of these special damages from the award of $10,-000.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit