District Court of Appeal of Florida December 6, 1968, No. 68-87 (Belle Terre Ass'n v. Brosch)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-12-1968

MANN, Judge.

Belle Terre is admittedly one of the more pleasant and gracious subdivisions in Dunedin. Since it was platted in 1924 a covenant running with the land has provided that “only one dwelling house (except for servants) shall be erected on any single lot or plot and each dwelling house shall be for one family only.” There is not the slightest suggestion that enforcement of this restriction has been rendered inequitable by supervening circumstance.

Corner lots, of which Lot 90 is one, are the larger lots of the 113 in the subdivision. Lot 90 has 110 feet frontage on one street and 100 on another. Richard A. Brosch and Mary M. Brosch, its owners, who were advised by letter dated September 11, 1967 that the Association would object to their plans to build two dwellings on Lot 90, recorded on that date deeds conveying the East 60 feet to Richard A. Brosch and the West 50 feet to Mary M. Brosch. Construction of a house on the easterly parcel was commenced soon thereafter and on October 6 Mary Brosch obtained a building permit *463for a house on the westerly parcel. This action for judgment declaring the restrictions valid ensued.

The circuit judge, reasoning correctly that the restrictions do not forbid conveyance of parts of a lot, denied the relief sought, and appellants and association of owners and individual residents of Belle Terre appeal. But the fact that a part of a lot may be conveyed does not invalidate the restrictions. Two owners could divide a third lot between them, for example.

The circuit court’s reliance on Schoolcraft Civic Ass’n v. Diloreto, 339 Mich. 121, 62 N.W.2d 657; Ingle v. Stubbins, 240 N.C. 382, 82 S.E.2d 388; Callaham v. Arenson, 239 N.C. 619, 80 S.E.2d 619 (1954); and Watts v. Fritz, 29 Ill.2d 517, 194 N.E.2d 276, and Hickson v. Noroton Manor, Inc., 118 Conn. 180, 171 A. 31, as the “weight of authority” is misplaced.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.