Louisiana Court of Appeal December 5, 1968, No. 2458 (Sittig v. Allstate Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1968
lead-opinion
HOOD, Judge.
Mr. and Mrs. Detroit M. Sittig instituted this action for damages for the wrongful death of their 16 year old son, Steven Sittig, who was killed when a motor scooter on which he was riding was struck by an automobile being driven by Harvey J. Trahan. The defendants are Trahan and his liability insurer, Allstate Insurance Company. The case was tried by jury, with the result that a general verdict was rendered in favor of defendants. Judgment was rendered in accordance with that verdict, and plaintiffs have appealed.
The issues presented on this appeal are: (1) Was Trahan negligent, and if so, was his negligence a proximate cause of the accident? (2) Are plaintiffs barred from recovery by the contributory negligence of the decedent? and (3) Did Trahan have the last clear chance to avoid the accident?
The accident occurred at about 7:30 p. m. on February 20, 1963, on Louisiana Highway 13, which is the principal thoroughfare between Eunice and Crowley. The highway at that point is a straight, level, two-lane, blacktopped road, which runs north and south, the asphalt pavement being 24 feet wide. The road was in good condition at the time of the accident, it having been improved shortly before that time, and there were wide, smooth shoulders on both sides of the pavement. It was dark at the time of the collision, but the weather was clear, the road was dry and visibility was good.
Plaintiffs’ residence is located on the east side of and adjacent to this highway. A private driveway leads from the home-place to the highway. Barricades had been constructed across both shoulders of this highway at a point 280 feet north of the Sittig driveway, and these barricades were in place at the time the accident occurred. Each of these barricades extended from the edge of the pavement, across the shoulder of the highway and into the ditch which ran along the side of the roadbed. The main traveled portion of the highway was not barricaded.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit