District Court of Appeal of Florida December 10, 1968, No. 67-991 (Friend v. Kapchuk)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-12-1968

WHITE, JOSEPH S., Associate Judge, Retired.

In this case plaintiffs have appealed from a final summary judgment dismissing their complaint. The judgment was entered upon defendants’ motion, plus certain discovery depositions and affidavits filed in conjunction with the hearing on the motion.

The complaint, filed in February, 1966, sought to impose a constructive trust on certain shares of stock held by defendants in a corporation, or in the alternative, upon treasury shares held by the corporation itself. It was alleged that the defendants had engaged in fraudulent conduct when they negotiated the transfer of certain other shares in the same corporation to plaintiffs.

The defendants affirmatively defended in the trial court by pleading that the plaintiffs were estopped because of the doctrine of laches and the statute of limi*784tations. The basis for this defense was the fact that the plaintiffs did not commence their lawsuit until February, 1966. Upon defendants’ motion for summary judgment, the trial court dismissed the complaint. This appeal has been taken to test the correctness of the court’s ruling. We do not find it necessary to discuss that part of the ruling which was premised on the statute of limitations; instead, we affirm the summary judgment on the basis of the doctrine of laches.

The negotiation in question which led to the transfer to plaintiffs took place during August, 1962. More than a year prior to this date, the defendants had re-organized the capital structure of the corporation by creating an issue of no par common stock with voting rights. They retained for themselves 15% of the authorized shares of the new stock issue.

The negotiations between the parties which took place during August, 1962, came about when the corporation became indebted to the plaintiffs and other creditors in such large amounts that it appeared to be insolvent and faced bankruptcy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.