Supreme Court of Arkansas September 16, 1968, 4638 (Wright v. Hulett)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-09-1968

Paul Ward, Justice.

This litigation is between Ivan C. Wright (appellant), a landlord, and Jarold Hulett (appellee), a lessee. The background facts, set out below, are not contested.

On November 15, 1966 appellant filed a complaint in chancery court alleging he had leased certain lands to appellee for the year 1966; that appellee planted 250 acres in beans and 20 acres in milo maize; that appellee agreed to pay, as rent, ^th of all crops — free from harvesting costs — and also agreed to harvest said crops at maturity. It was further alleged that appellee failed to harvest said crops at maturity, and that he owed $500 for money advanced for planting and cultivation. Appellant’s prayer was that he be allowed to enter and harvest the crops; that he be given judgment for cost of harvesting and also for the $500 advanced.

On motion by appellee the cause was transferred to the circuit court — without objections — and, on January 18, 1967 appellant filed therein an “amended and substituted complaint”, making substantially the same allegations as previously made and asking judgment for the $500 and $908 for damages to the crops. The above allegations were denied by appellee in his answer.

A jury trial was had and, on December 18, 1967, a verdict (and judgment) was entered in favor of appellee, and this appeal follows.

Seeking a reversal, appellant relies on only one point: The court erred in refusing to allow appellant to introduce in evidence his complaint filed in the chancery court.

It is our conclusion that the trial court did not commit reversible error. In the first place, appellant had a right to testify concerning the subject matter in the original complaint, and he did, in fact, so testify. Consequently it is difficult to understand how he has been prejudiced by the court’s ruling.

Moreover, it appears that the trial court would have erred had it allowed the complaint (in the chancery court) to be introduced in evidence. In 29 Am. Jur.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.