Superior Court of Pennsylvania May 10, 1968, Appeals, Nos. 108 and 109 (Commonwealth v. Frazier)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-05-1968
lead-opinion
Opinion
Per Curiam,
Judgments of sentence affirmed.
concurrence-opinion
Concurring Opinion by
Montgomery, J.:
I concur in the per curiam order of affirmance in this case for the reasons hereinafter stated.
Appellant was charged with raping the prosecutrix Annie Battles, who positively identified him at the trial as one of five persons who had dragged her into an alley and raped her three times. During the incident the police arrived and shot one of the fleeing group. That one was this appellant who was immediately apprehended, taken to the police station and identified by the victim.
At the nonjury trial before the Honorable Stanley M. Greenberg, Judge, the clothing the appellant had been wearing was produced and Mrs. Agnes Malatratt Douglas (sometimes referred to as Mrs. Agnes Malatratt), a person described as a criminalistic technician employed by the City of Philadelphia, testified that a hole in the clothing was a bullet hole and that certain stains thereon were bloodstains. This witness had, previous to this trial, appeared in the courts of Philadelphia on many cases in her capacity as an expert in her field, and in fact she was recognized generally as a person of great knowledge of such matters by reason of her twenty years of experience. Although appellant’s counsel was not familiar with her, Judge Green-berg was, and on his statement to that effect appellant’s counsel stipulated that she was qualified to testify as an expert in such matters.
*217Subsequent to this trial Mrs. Douglas admitted in another trial that when she had been first employed by the City of Philadelphia she had falsely stated that she was “a certified medical technician” from Temple University, when, in fact, she had no such certificate. The only issue raised in this appeal is whether such subsequent admission of a false statement constitutes after-discovered evidence as to require a new trial.
Appellant cites the cases of Gay v. Graham, 269 F. 2d 482 (10th Cir.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit