United States Court of Military Appeals November 29, 1968, No. 21,006 (United States v. Blue)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-11-1968
Opinion of the Court
Quinn, Chief Judge:
The accused was charged with larceny of over $1,000.00 from Ship’s Store Number One aboard the U.S.S. VALLEY FORGE, but the special court-martial to which the charge was referred for trial found him guilty of larceny of only $300.00. On review, the general court-martial authority approved findings of guilty of the lesser offense of wrongful appropriation. This finding was consistent with admissions made by the accused in a pretrial statement and with the plea of guilty to wrongful appropriation in the amount of $300.00, which he entered at trial. On this appeal, however, the accused contends that an unsworn statement made by him during the sentence proceedings was inconsistent with his plea, and further inquiry into its providence should have been made. Manual *40for Courts-Martial, United States, 1951, paragraphs 706 and 75; United States v Cleveland, 15 USCMA 121, 35 CMR 93.
The accused was designated operator of Ship’s Store Number One. Before he assumed his duties, a physical inventory was made of ail articles in the store. The accused certified the inventory. At the next regular inventory, a dollar shortage in excess of $1,000.00 was discovered. Ship’s Servicemen “worked day and night” in an attempt to find the possible error, but did not succeed. Some evidence indicated that several acts of pilferage by other persons may have taken place in the interim between inventories. The matter was referred to the Office of Naval Intelligence for investigation. In the course of this investigation, the accused made a handwritten incriminating statement, which was admitted into evidence at the trial. As indicated more fully below, the accused confessed that he took “about” $300.00 from the cash receipts, but he denied responsibility for the balance of the shortage disclosed by the inventory. The court-martial apparently accepted this part of the accused’s statement as true because it found him guilty of larceny of only $300.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit