Michigan Court of Appeals June 26, 1969, Docket 5,406, 5,407 (Bartnicki v. Wayne County Drain Commissioner)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-06-1969
McGregor, J.
The two cases herein discussed concern the same facts, allegations, and defendants. The plaintiffs are two groups of people who unsuccessfully filed class actions in the lower court. Our decision disposes of "both their appeals.
The lower court actions stemmed from drainage improvements petitioned for in 1957 and completed in late 1961. The sale of bonds to finance the’ drainage work was delayed by a lawsuit filed in 1960, in which some of the plaintiffs participated. See
Landowners of Sexton-Kilfoil Drainage District
v.
Wayne County Drain Commissioner
(1962), 367 Mich 150. After the Supreme Court determined that the drain proceedings were valid, the bond sale and work commenced. The order issued by the drainage board to the drain commissioner indicated that the defendant municipalities were to be assessed for part of the cost of the improvement. Apparently they were not,
*203
and the plaintiffs allege constructive fraud. Defendants filed motions for summary judgment in both actions which, after being granted by the lower court on the grounds of no cause of action, were appealed.
The issue posed is whether the court correctly granted defendants’ motions for summary judgment.
The thread of plaintiffs’ argument is that the failure to assess the defendant municipalities for the drainage improvement cost constituted fraud or constructive fraud, and thus they have an equitable claim for relief. They contend they had no notice of the fraud at the time of the original failure to assess, and thus their actions, filed on discovery of the fraud, were timely. Plaintiffs requested an equitable order by the court, ordering the municipalities to comply with the drainage board’s order to pay their share of the improvement cost. As a basis for their contentions, plaintiffs use various equitable principles embedded in legal tradition.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit