Supreme Court of South Carolina November 12, 1969, 18984 (Stevens v. McGaha)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-11-1969

Brailsford, Justice.

Three-year-old Gregory Stevens lost the sight of his left eye when it was lacerated by a sharp, jagged corner of the protruding metal handle of a chest type freezer in the kitchen of his grandfather’s home. This action for damages was brought against Clint McGaha, the grandfather, and the manufacturer and retailer of the freezer. Voluntary nonsuits were taken as to the manufacturer and retailer, and the grandfather appeals from an adverse judgment.

The first and second exceptions challenge the sufficiency of the evidence to sustain the verdict. This issue is not properly before us because the record does not show that a motion for nonsuit or directed verdict was made at the trial on this ground. Circuit Court Rule 76;

Evans v. Wabash Life Ins. Co,.

247 S. C. 464, 148 S. E. (2d) 153 (1966). We add that the issue of actionable negligence was clearly for the jury under the principles stated in

Lynch v. Motel Enterprises, Inc.,

248 S. C. 490, 151 S. E. (2d) 435 (1966), and

Everett v. White,

245 S. C. 331, 140 S. E. (2d) 582 (1965), and the authorities therein cited.

The trial was commenced on October 14, and the testimony was completed on that day. When court opened next morning, counsel for the defendant moved for a mistrial “on the grounds of a newspaper article appearing in the local paper.” Error in overruling this motion is assigned by the third exception.

The article in question contained the erroneous statement that “(t)he suit is a ‘home policy’ type in which the grand

*381

father contends that his insurance protects him in the event of a suit from such an accident.” The court by appropriate inquiry ascertained that the newspaper story had come to the attentiton of only two of the jurors. In response to the court’s questions, these two jurors stated that the article would not affect their verdict in the slightest degree. Appropriate additional instructions, conforming to the wishes of counsel, were given to the jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.