Michigan Court of Appeals October 29, 1969, Docket 4,462 (People v. Manier)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-10-1969
McGregor, J.
The people’s attempt to convict the defendant was conducted in a manner which necessitates reversal. Defendant appeals his conviction of violating MCLA § 750.335a (Stat Ann 1954 Eev § 28.567 [1]), the indecent exposure of his person.
The facts presented on this appeal are not disputed by the parties. The record shows that complainant was working at a party store in Detroit on August 16, 1966. Between 10:30 and 11 p.m. she saw a car drive up to the curb in front of the store. Complainant turned her back to the street, and when she heard no one leave the car, she looked again into the street. It was at this time that she observed a man masturbating in the car. She got a final glimpse as she went outside to write down the license number. Immediately after the incident, she telephoned the police.
The complainant could not make a positive identification of the defendant at the showup. At trial, she purportedly made an identification, but admitted she could not identify him, from a front view. A policewoman took the stand and testified that, based on the records of the police department, the license number received from complainant, which was included in the police report, indicated the car was owned by the defendant.
Assuming without deciding that the license number received from the complainant was not hearsay, other evidentiary violations have occurred. There
*605
was a need to correlate the license number in the police report and the owner of the car through appropriate records in order to connect the defendant with the car and, through that, with the crime. The officer sought to do this merely by checking the Detroit police records and making an oral report in the court. This testimony was objected to as hearsay. The people did not offer these written records.
It is clear that these public records are themselves hearsay evidence, but they are considered trustworthy because they are kept by public officials who are under sanction of oath of office.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit