Supreme Court of Iowa March 11, 1969, 53292 (Crozier v. Iowa-Illinois Gas & Electric Company)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-03-1969
STUART, Justice.
A right of way easement for high-voltage electric transmission lines was acquired
*834
by condemnation. Plaintiffs appealed from the condemnation award of the sheriff’s jury to the district court and now bring this appeal claiming the trial court erred in permitting testimony relating to “comparable sales” and that the jury verdict was inadequate and unresponsive to the instructions.
On February 7, 1966 Iowa-Illinois Gas and Electric Company condemned a right of way across 5.5 acres of plaintiffs’ timber pasture. The construction and maintenance of the line required that the strip of land 180/ in width and 1346’ in length be cleared of trees and brush. No land was taken.
The timber pasture within the easement had been used for plaintiffs’ unique and financially rewarding wilderness hog farrowing operation from 1964 until condemnation. Plaintiffs started improving the 10 acre timber pasture area which was sandy, steep sloped for good drainage, and tree covered with undergrowth and brush in 1962. The area was bounded by a hog-tight fence. Plaintiffs drilled wells from which water was pumped to 5 drinking tanks and rocked the waterways. There were cross fences within the area. The wilderness hog farrowing timber pasture was readily accessible from plaintiffs’ buildings.
Plaintiffs’ witnesses testified this method of farrowing pigs was more efficient because it produced less disease and required less labor than other farrowing methods. All witnesses agreed plaintiffs’ wilderness hog farrowing operation had been destroyed by cutting the trees, clearing the underbrush, and installing the transmission lines.
Plaintiffs’ valuation witnesses' stated the fair market value of the Crozier farm was $30,000 to $50,000 more before condemnation than it was after condemnation. Defendant’s valuation witnesses stated the difference was between $500 and $560. The sheriff’s condemnation jury awarded plaintiffs $5,000 and on appeal the district court jury awarded $4,000.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit