Michigan Court of Appeals December 22, 1969, Docket 6,215 (Nemer v. Michigan State Board of Registration for Architects, Professional Engineers & Land Surveyors)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1969

Opinion as Amended by Order op December 12, 1969.

Bronson, J.

This is not plaintiff’s first encounter

with defendant in this Court. In

Nemer

v.

State Board of Registration for Architects, Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors

(1966), 5 Mich App 286, plaintiff sought judicial review of defendant’s failure to certify plaintiff as an architect. In the first

Nemer

case, plaintiff sought to have defendant board declared unconstitutional because a majority of its members were not architects. See Const 1963, art 5, § 5. There we held that such a contention was premature and inconsistent with the relief then sought. We further indicated that if plaintiff wished to pursue such a course, his proper procedure would be

quo warranto

under GCR 1963, 715. The instant case is the culmination of our suggestion.

Since the first suit, plaintiff has become a duly licensed architect in the State of Michigan. As such, his professional activities are subject to the

*432

scrutiny of defendant. Plaintiff -wishes this scrutiny to cease. He contends that defendant is unconstitutionally composed because only three of its seven members are architects and the Constitution requires :

“A majority of the members of an appointed examining or licensing board of a profession shall be members of that profession.” Const 1963, art 5, § 5.

The Attorney General, representing defendant, contends

quo warranto

is an inappropriate procedural vehicle. This is a spurious argument in light of the prior ease between the same parties. There, the Attorney General’s brief suggested plaintiff institute

quo warranto

to test defendant’s constitutionality. Our Court agreed and in the opinion stated:

“If plaintiff questions the right of defendant board to perform its functions, his proper procedure would be an action for

quo warranto.”

The Attorney General’s inconsistency has little to commend it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.