California Court of Appeal December 10, 1969, Crim. 15752 (People v. Boone)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-12-1969

Opinion

FLEMING, J.

In view of the fact that the arresting officers were dressed in plainclothes and using an unmarked vehicle when they forced entry into defendant’s residence at night, can we hold that the requirements of section 844 of the Penal Code had been met?

We have heretofore identified the essential requirements of section 844 as (1) identification of themselves by the police; (2) explanation of their purpose; and (3) demand for entry.

(People

v.

Superior Court,

274 Cal.App. 2d 578 [79 Cal.Rptr. 55].) These requirements may be satisfied by literal

*506

compliance, or by substantial compliance, or their performance in a given instance may be excused.

Literal compliance is not a factor here, and hence requires no comment.

Substantial compliance expresses a rule of interpretation which derives from general maxims of equity—that substance governs over form, that no one is required to perform an idle act. (Civ. Code, §§ 3528, 3532.) Hence if the essence of a requirement has been met, or if its performance would be superfluous, then the law holds that the requirement has been substantially complied with. The application of the rule may be seen in

People

v.

Cockrell,

63 Cal.2d 659 [47 Cal.Rptr. 788, 408 P.2d 116], which upheld the police identification and request for entry in that case and in

People

v.

Marshall,

69 Cal.2d 51 [69 Cal.Rptr. 585, 442 P.2d 665], which held that persistent knocking by the police, announcement of their identity, and demand for entry complied with the section. The limits of the rule of substantial compliance appear in

People

v.

Rosales,

68 Cal.2d 299, 302 [66 Cal.Rptr. 1, 437 P.2d 489], which held that police identification without a demand for entry or explanation of purpose did not amount to substantial compliance with the statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.