California Court of Appeal September 23, 1969, Civ. 33920 (Trujillo v. City of Los Angeles)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-09-1969

damus the trial court entered a judgment ordering defendants to re-create the position of manager of harbor real estate, Harbor Department, City of Los Angeles and to reinstate petitioner Trujillo to said position, and directing payment of his salary, less amounts paid to him in a subordinate position, from date of abolition of the position to date of reinstatement.

Defendants appeal from the judgment, contending the trial court erred (1) in permitting the introduction of extraneous evidence of motives of the board of harbor commissioners in abolishing petitioner’s position, and (2) in holding that petitioner’s subsequent resignation from a subordinate position and withdrawal of his pension contributions did not constitute a severance of his employment rights.

Defendants request that the case be remanded for the purpose of taking additional evidence to determine whether petitioner has received remuneration during the interim period from other employment. Defendants also petition this court,

*336

pursuant to section 909, Code of Civil Procedure, and rule 23, California Rules of Court, for leave to produce additional evidence on appeal as to the effect a November 1968 reorganization of the harbor department has on petitioner’s rights.

1

In 1955, acting upon recommendations of an independent management consulting firm, the Los Angeles Harbor Department created the civil service position of manager of harbor real estate to manage in excess of 1,000 acres of valuable harbor land, either under lease or available for lease, under the jurisdiction of the harbor department. The position was placed under the immediate supervision of the general manager, harbor department. Departmental procedure was for the real estate manager to negotiate and review leases, to submit proposals to the general manager for review, and if approved, the proposals would then be submitted to the board of harbor commissioners for final approval.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.