Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit August 28, 1969, 27132_1 (In the Matter of John M. Sturdevant, Bankrupt. John M. Sturdevant v. Robert C. Maley, Jr., Trustee)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-08-1969

*466

GEWIN, Circuit Judge:

The appellant, Sturdevant, filed a voluntary petition in bankruptcy in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas.

1

The Texas National Bank of Commerce of Houston, a creditor of the bankrupt, filed objections to the bankrupt’s discharge quoting as grounds for their objection the provisions of 11 U.S.C. §§ 32(c) (3) and 32(c) (7) (1964).

2

By way of amplification of the claim based on § 32(c) (3), the bank alleged that the bankrupt had “ * * * furnished to movant a materially false financial statement to obtain money in the form of a loan.”

Bankrupt promptly filed a motion to dismiss the bank’s objections to discharge, or in the alternative, a motion for a more definite statement of the objections. Upon hearing, the Referee granted bankrupt’s motion to dismiss as to the allegation based on § 32(c) (7), because, at best, it was a mere quotation of the language of that section. The Referee denied bankrupt’s motion to dismiss the allegation based on § 32(c) (3), relating to the use of a false financial statement, but required the bank to amend this objection to show the transaction to which its, allegation referred. The bank filed its amended specifications of objections to discharge after the last day fixed for filing objections to discharge, but within the time allowed by the Referee’s order. The bankrupt then filed a motion to dismiss or alternatively to strike the amended specifications of objections to discharge. The Referee denied this motion. The bankrupt then sought review by the district court. The district court denied the petition for review adopting and affirming the findings of the Referee.

Bankrupt asserts essentially two bases for reversal of the district court: (1) that the original objections to discharge were not amendable, (2) that the objections as amended were insufficient. After considering these arguments, we affirm.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.