Court of Appeals of Washington October 15, 1969, No. 61-40438-1 (National Electrical Contractors Ass'n v. City of Bellevue)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1969

Farris, J.

In 1966, the City of Bellevue (hereinafter called the City) determined to install several traffic control installations. No firm schedule was set, the installations to be completed at the discretion of the City.

The plaintiff, National Electrical Contractors Association, Puget Sound Chapter, (hereinafter called the Association) insisted that the various installations could not be done without the City first calling for public bids. This action was commenced to enjoin the City from proceeding without public bids.

At issue is the operation of RCW 35.23.352:

Any city or town of the second, third or fourth class may construct any public work or improvement by contract or day labor without calling for bids therefor whenever the estimated cost of such work or improvement, including cost of materials, supplies and equipment will not exceed the sum of five thousand dollars. Whenever the cost . . . will exceed five thousand dollars, the same shall be done by contract. All such contracts shall be let at public bidding . . .

All parties agree that the issue is whether a third class city can, under RCW 35.23.352, separate work and material in determining whether an improvement exceeds the cost of $5,000.

The essential facts are not in dispute. The total cost of each traffic control installation (including the cost of material and labor) exceeds $5,000. As to one intersection now complete, the following took place:

*83In 1967, the City purchased signal control equipment without taking bids.............$2,327.13

In 1967, the City purchased additional equipment with bids....................... 1,746.00

In 1968, the City negotiated with a contractor to install the equipment......... 2,434.85

In 1968, the City used its own personnel to complete the installation................. 565.15

Thus the total cost of the intersection was: $7,073.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.