Circuit Court of the 11th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Miami-Dade County November 6, 1969, No. 68-11218 (Dade County v. Abbat)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-11-1969

JAMES LAWRENCE KING, Circuit Judge.

Order of apportionment: This cause came before the court on x petition for apportionment filed by the defendants Buhlers and the Jupiter Corporation and by the defendant fee-owners as to parcel nos. 1-19, 2-19, 4-19, 8-19, *9-19, 13-19, 17-19, 18-19, 21-19, 22-19, 24-19, 25-19, 26-19, 28-19, 29-19, 31-19, 33-19, 34-19 and 43-19.

Petitioning defendants, Buhlers and the Jupiter Corporation, presented the testimony of Ernest R. Smith by deposition taken on July 11, 1969 pursuant to this court’s order entered from the petitioner’s objection to the notice of taking Mr. Smith’s deposition and motion to disallow the same. By stipulation of all counsel, the deposition of Ernest Smith was reviewed by the court subject to all objections raised in said deposition. The defendants also presented testimony of Dan C. Shay, geologist, and introduced into evidence a single quit-claim deed indicating a conveyance from John M. Murrel, et ux. to Sham G. Sani, as trustee, dated February 11, 1969, recorded in O.R.B. 303, page 518, public records of Collier County. Valuation date in this action was October 10, 1968.

At the conclusion of the evidence presented by petitioning defendants, Buhlers and the Jupiter Corporation, the defendant fee-owners moved for a directed verdict and to strike the deposition testimony of Ernest R. Smith. The court reserved ruling upon the motion for directed verdict pending an opportunity to review the evidence in full, including the deposition of Ernest R. Smith, subject to all objections therein made.

The defendant fee-owners assert that no part of the deposition testimony of Smith may be considered by the court because, allegedly, Mr. Smith demonstrated no qualifications as an expert to provide a legal predicate for the acceptance of his testimony.

Having fully considered all evidence presented by defendants Buhlers and Jupiter Corporation, including the deed from Murrell, et ux.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.