Supreme Court of Missouri November 10, 1969, No. 54259 (Estate of Stevenson v. David)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-11-1969

HENRY I. EAGER, Special Commissioner.

This proceeding involves one phase of the method used in computing the Missouri Inheritance Tax. There is really only one issue, and the facts are not in controversy. We have jurisdiction because a state officer is a party and a construction of the revenue laws is required, although the amount actually involved is $1451.17.

Beatrice L. Stevenson, a resident of the City of St. Louis, died on November 8, 1963. Her gross estate, consisting chiefly of stocks and bonds, had a gross value of $736,635.85 at the time of her death. Executors were duly appointed; an inheritance tax appraiser was also appointed. The latter filed his report on May 11, 1967, fixing all valuations as of the date of the death, and allowing deductions for debts, taxes and expenses of administration. The tax was reported as $42,364.87. Among the deductions were listed executors’ commissions in the amount of $36,-831.79 and attorney’s fees of $19,965.90. Those deductions were computed upon the percentages prescribed in § 473.153, RSMo 1959, V.A.M.S.,1 and were based upon the valuation of the property at death. In the meantime the value of the estate had increased substantially and, when computed to include all distributions, the payment of approved claims and allowances, and cash and securities on hand it totaled $879,879.24; such was the finding of the circuit court.

We pause here to state the principal contentions of the parties, for the sake of clarity. The representatives of the estate claim that the deductions for commissions and attorney’s fees should have been computed on the proper percentages of $879,879.24 because such was the value of the personal property administered. See § 473.153. That computation would presumably have fixed the commissions at $44,267.00 and the attorney’s fees at $23,683.50. See § 473.153(2), (3). Such amounts were allowed by the Probate Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.