Court of Appeals of Kentucky November 13, 1969 (Carpenter v. Haydon)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-11-1969
DAVIS, Commissioner.
Albert Haydon obtained a judgment against C. N. Carpenter (sometimes referred to in this record as C. M. Carpenter) for $3,000 as property damage to a truck allegedly forced from the highway by a truck owned by Carpenter and operated by his employee. Carpenter challenges the judgment charging that (1) Haydon did not adequately prove his claim for damages, and (2) there was insufficient identification of Carpenter’s truck as the offending vehicle.
*352According to evidence for appellee, a southbound truck owned by him was forced off Highway 421 on September 18, 1961, by a northbound truck owned by the appellant and operated by his employee. The offending truck did not stop, and the critical question in the case is whether there was sufficient evidence to warrant a jury’s finding that the offending truck was, in fact, one owned by Carpenter and operated by his employee.
As noted, a preliminary question is presented as to whether the appellee presented competent evidence reflecting damages to his truck. The appellant concedes that the appellee demonstrated appropriate knowledge of truck values to express his opinion concerning the before value of the truck. He contends that there was no showing that the appellee possessed such experience and knowledge as would permit him to express his opinion of the after value of the wrecked vehicle. We are not impressed by the argument, particularly in view of the fact that there was evidence indicating that the wrecked vehicle was a total loss although appellee expressed the view that its after value was $750. This court has long taken the practical view that an ordinary witness who testifies that he knows the market value of an auotmobile is competent to express his view of such value and is not required to be an expert or have special qualifications for that purpose. See Williams v. Kirtley, Ky., 263 S.W.2d 119, 121.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit