Michigan Court of Appeals January 30, 1969, Docket No. 3,041 (Adams v. Emery Transportation Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-01-1969
Fitzgerald, J.
An unusual state of facts frequently can lead to an unusual result in the law, *595or, as is more commonly paraphrased, “hard cases make bad law”.1 It is just such a hard case and bad law that we delineate in this appeal.
Basically, we are confronted with a situation where an injured employee has received approximately $7,000 compensation from his “employer” in the State of Illinois for an injury suffered in Brand Rapids, Michigan. He has now been awarded a recovery in the State of Michigan against a so-called “different” employer for the identical injury. The ingredients for this legal jumble are one claimant, one accident, but a double recovery due to the convoluted fact situation.
In 1948 or 1949, plaintiff began working as a long-distance truck driver for Midwest Transfer Company of Illinois. He also drove trucks on occasion for Emery Transportation Company, an Ohio corporation. The companies were commonly owned and managed, and ultimately merged in December of 1961 into Midwest Emery Freight System, Inc. Sometime in June of 1960, plaintiff injured his back while unloading a truck in Brand Rapids.
On February 17,1961, plaintiff filed an application for workmen’s compensation benefits with the Illinois Industrial Commission alleging an injury on June 8, 1960, while in the employ of Midwest. On June 28, 1961, he also filed an application for hearing and adjustment of claim with the Michigan Workmen’s Compensation Department against both Midwest and Emery, alleging the injury occurred on June 1, 1960 (it is admitted by all concerned that plaintiff suffered only one injury).
On June 15, 1962, plaintiff settled his Illinois claim with Midwest for $7,000. The settlement agreement, approved by the Illinois Industrial Com*596mission, recited that it represented full payment for the injury, that Illinois had exclusive jurisdiction over the matter, and that plaintiff would dismiss his Michigan proceedings.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit