Michigan Court of Appeals May 27, 1969, Docket No. 4,446 (Lopetrone v. Roma Catering Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-05-1969
*251On Rehearing.
Per Curiam.
Plaintiff, John Lopetrone, sued defendant, Eoma Catering Company, Inc., for money allegedly owed plaintiff under the terms of a collective bargaining contract. The trial judge concluded that although defendant had violated the terms of the collective bargaining contract by paying plaintiff at the rate of $2 per hour, plaintiff failed to present a fairly reliable standard of determining damages. However, plaintiff did substantiate his hours from March 2, 1965, through and including October 30, 1965.
The trial court, sitting without a jury, held that plaintiff was entitled to recover $488 plus costs of $23. Prom this decision plaintiff appeals seeking recovery for the years 1960 to March, 1965.
On reconsideration, we feel constrained to reverse our decision in Lopetrone v. Roma Catering Company, Inc. (1969), 17 Mich App 386. As we noted in that previous decision, an examination of the record and the lower court’s opinion shows that there is some confusion as to which contract was in force in 1960, and whether plaintiff was paid at the rate of $2 per hour at all times.
One source of confusion in this case is that the trial judge was interpreting a contract which provided that bartenders were to be paid $17.50 for an eight-hour day, provided that the bartender worked a minimum of two hours. Clearly, unless plaintiff could establish with some particularity that he worked at least two hours on a given day, the contract does not indicate that the payment of $2 per hour is improper. However, the contract before this Court, which was effective June 1, 1963, makes no requirement of working two hours. The contract *252simply states that a bartender is entitled to $17.50 for working eight hours or less.
Plaintiff argues in this appeal that the reason he was prevented from proving the hours he worked was because of the failure of the defendant to keep proper records.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit