Nevada Supreme Court March 7, 1969, No. 5644 (Houlden v. Discount Motors, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-03-1969

OPINION

By the Court,

Zenoff, J.:

The driver of a 1956 automobile, Robert Muldowney, drove into Wilbert Houlden and his pregnant wife at between 35 and 45 miles per hour as they walked on the highway in a crosswalk towards the Desert Inn Hotel near Las Vegas. The wife was killed, the baby was delivered dead, and Houlden was severely injured. Muldowney was subsequently convicted of involuntary manslaughter. His insurance company paid Houlden $20,000.

Houlden sought additional recovery from Discount Motors, Inc., for allegedly selling Muldowney the car with worn-out brake linings. Houlden contended that had the brakes been adequate Muldowney would have been able to stop and the accident would have been prevented. A jury trial ended in a verdict finding .Muldowney causally negligent and Discount Motors, Inc., not causally negligent. Houlden appeals from judgment in favor of- Discount Motors.

1. Respondent Discount Motors, Inc., defends this appeal simply on the ground that the evidence does not support the contention that Muldowney applied the brakes before he struck the Houldens so the question of defective brakes is immaterial *127to liability. The only evidence that the brakes may have been applied at all did not come from Muldowney who was not sure whether he used the brakes or not. Two persons, Mr. and Mrs. Tullis, testified that they did not see the impact but almost simultaneously heard a screeching of brakes and then a thud. Muldowney said that he did not see the Houldens until they were within 20 feet of him. Before that, he was able to stop the car at the previous intersection and also to stop within 100 feet after the accident. A bus driver who saw the entire incident said he never saw Muldowney’s brake lights go on and that his speed did not diminish until after the collision. Since the evidence clearly preponderated towards the conclusion that Muldowney did not apply his brakes, the judgment must be affirmed if no harmful error occurred at the trial.

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.