District Court, E.D. Kentucky December 30, 1969, Nos. 2006-2008 (Carson v. U-Haul Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-12-1969
MEMORANDUM
SWINFORD, Chief Judge.
Plaintiffs, John Carson, Betty Lou Carson and Fred William Carson, were allegedly injured when the automobile in which they were traveling was struck by another automobile driven by the defendant, James Michael Gracey. Plaintiffs contend that the accident was caused by the defective braking condition of a trailer leased from the defendants, U-Haul Co. and Arcoa, Inc., and towed by Gracey at the time of the accident. This accident occurred November' 15, 1965, in the eastern federal district of Kentucky. The plaintiffs are citizens of Georgia. The defendants are James Michael Gracey, a citizen of Kentucky; U-Haul Co., a corporation incorporated in Kentucky with its principal place of business in Tennessee; and, Arcoa, Inc., a coiporation incorporated in Oregon with its principal place of business in Oregon.
Based on diversity of citizenship, the plaintiffs attempted to recover for their alleged injuries by commencing suits against the named defendants in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division. Service of process on defendants U-Haul Co. and Arcoa, Inc. was to be accomplished by serving the Georgia Secretary of State under a Georgia “doing business” statute. No method of serving process on defendant Gracey was proposed. The complaints of plaintiffs John Carson and Betty Lou Carson were filed October 19, 1967. The complaint of plaintiff Fred William Carson was filed the next day.
Gracey did not consent to the jurisdiction of the Georgia district court. U-Haul Co. and Arcoa, Inc. challenged *1088their service under the Georgia “doing business” statute by contending that they in fact were not conducting business in Georgia. After a series of interrogatories failed to produce any tangible results, plaintiffs on February 24, 1969, moved to transfer the actions from the Georgia district court to this court. The cases were ordered transferred on March 14, 1969.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit