Michigan Court of Appeals August 24, 1970, Docket 110 (People v. Henley)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-08-1970

J. H. Gillis, J.

This case is here by order of the Supreme Court remanding the record “for ascertainment therefrom of facts which will fairly frame the alleged issue of double jeopardy and for a judicial determination thereof”.

People

v.

Henley

(1969), 382 Mich 143, 150,

reversing

(1965), 2 Mich App 54. The question presented is whether the defense of double jeopardy was available as a bar to the retrial of defendant Henley, after his previous trial had

*18

ended abortively when the trial court,

sua sponte,

declared a mistrial.

We state the facts solely as they relate to the issue of double jeopardy.

I

On June 20, 1963, defendant was arraigned on a warrant charging (1) assault with intent to commit rape (MCLA § 750.85 [Stat Ann 1962 Rev § 28.280]) and (2) attempt to procure an act of gross indecency between male and female persons (MCLA § 750.338b [Stat Ann 1964 Rev § 28.570(2)]). An attorney was assigned by the court to represent the defendant and an examination was conducted in Recorder’s Court on July 11, 1963. On October 24, 1963, defendant advised the court that he desired to engage his own counsel and that he did not want assigned counsel. The court permitted assigned counsel to withdraw from the case. Several adjournments of the case were granted in order that defendant might retain counsel of his own choosing.

Trial was scheduled for December 12, 1963. As of December 9, defendant had not retained counsel and on that date he was offered another assigned counsel by the then presiding judge of the Recorder’s Court. The defendant refused, however, to sign the required affidavit and petition for appointment of counsel. The following colloquy took place between defendant and the court:

“The Court:

Mr. William J. Coughlin was assigned counsel in July. He has some difficulty with his client who insisted he was going to get his own lawyer. Judge Krause permitted Mr. Coughlin to resign.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.