California Court of Appeal October 23, 1970, Docket Nos. 26094, 26418 (Campbell Chain Co. v. County of Alameda)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-10-1970

Opinion

TAYLOR, J.

In this consolidated matter, several corporate taxpayers sought to recover property taxes paid to respondents under protest (Rev.

&

Tax. Code, § 5138) for the 1966 tax year. The appeals are from two judgments of the superior court after a consolidated trial

1

to review the

*252

action of the Alameda County Board of Supervisors, acting as a board of equalization (hereafter Board). Appellants contend that substantial evidence supports their assertion that the Alameda County Assessor (hereafter Assessor) applied different assessment ratios to different classes of property, in violation of the constitutional prohibition against unfair and discriminatory assessments, and that the Board erroneously excluded certain proffered evidence.

The basic facts are not in dispute. On the applicable tax date, March 1, 1966, the respective appellants were the owners of certain business personal property and commercial real property.

2

Appellants stipulated that the appraisals of market value of their property made by the Assessor were correct as the fair market value of the different classes of property they owned, and that the 40 percent assessment ratio

3

was applied to the “full cash value” of each class of property. The gist of their complaint for a reduction before the Board was that the

full cash value figure

to which the 40 percent ratio was applied was a different percent of fair market value for each class of property. The Assessor indicated that the figure denominated as “full cash value” was 100 percent of fair market value

for business personal property,

70 percent of fair market value

for commercial and industrial real property,

and 54 percent of fair market value

for residential real property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.