Indiana Supreme Court December 18, 1970, 269S25 (Wheeler v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-1970

Arterburn, J.

The appellant was indicted for first degree murder by the Delaware County Grand Jury. The appellant having pleaded not guilty, after trial of said matter the jury

*397

returned a verdict of guilty to the .charge of first degree murder and assessed the defendant’s punishment as life in prison.

Evidence introduced at the trial indicates that on February 4, 1967, the decedent, Zula Fletcher, was driven home by her son after an evening spent visiting friends. He let her out of his car and waited to see if her third-floor apartment light would come on, signifying she had entered safely. Her light never came on. Two of the decedent’s neighbors heard a scream. One of them, Harriett Thornburg, went downstairs to ask her niece if she had screamed, and while talking to her niece, she saw defendant going down the stairs. Her niece also saw the defendant leaving the apartment building. Both identified the defendant at trial. They went upstairs to the third floor where the decedent lived and were looking around when Mr. Fletcher, the decedent’s son, came upstairs and found his mother in her apartment with her head bashed in. There were pry marks on Mrs. Fletcher’s door and wood splinters on the floor. Her apartment had been ransacked, there was a pool of blood on the floor, and her broken glasses were lying on the floor. Defendant was arrested a few hours later, after an attempt to escape being arrested. Defendant’s clothing contained blood spots of the same type as Zula Fletcher’s but of a type different than his own. Defendant’s shoe sole contained a sliver of glass which was testified to as having come from the broken glasses of the decedent.

The defendant first argues on appeal that by the exclusion from the jury of persons who do not believe in the death penalty, the defendant has been denied the right to a fair cross section of the population of the county where the crime was alleged to have been committed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.