Circuit Court of the 11th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Miami-Dade County May 5, 1970, No. 69-17689 (Fleetwood Hotel, Inc. v. City of Miami Beach)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-1970

JACK A. FALK, Circuit Judge.

Final summary judgment: This cause came on for hearing on plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment. The court having considered the pleadings (including the defendant’s motion for summary judgment), the argument of counsel and being otherwise fully advised in the premises, finds that the question whether an emergency existed in the city of Miami Beach either at the time of the enactment of ordinance no. 1791 (the “rent control ordinance”), or at this time, is not before the court. The court further finds that the plaintiffs have waived their objection to the validity of the enactment of the rent control ordinance with respect to the three readings required by the charter of the city of Miami Beach. (The court has allowed to be placed in the record ordinance no. 1791 as subsequently re-read three times by the city council of the city of Miami Beach.)

*193The court finds that the only issues before it are the following —

Whether the city of Miami Beach has the power to enact a rent control ordinance.

Whether the ordinance amounts to an unlawful delegation of the legislative authority of the city council of the city of Miami Beach.

Whether the ordinance conflicts with state law, particularly chapter 83, Florida Statutes.

As to the first issue, the court concludes that a city has no inherent police power other than that which is specifically delegated to it. Perry Trading Co. v. City of Tallahassee, 128 Fla. 424, 174 So. 854 (1937). Moreover it is the conclusion of the court that the weight of authority is that under the circumstances, the city of Miami Beach does not have the power (either incident to its specific powers or under its “general welfare” powers) to enact a rent control ordinance. See Tietjens v. City of St. Louis, 222 S. W. 2d 70 (Mo. 1949); Old Colony Gardens v. City of Stamford, 147 Conn. 60, 156 A. 2d 515 (1959); Wagner v. City of Newark, 24 N.J. 467, 132 A. 2d (1957); and, Grofo Realty Co. v. City of Bayonne, 24 N.J.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.