Circuit Court of the 5th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Lake County March 9, 1970, No. 111 (Grizzard v. City of Leesburg)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-03-1970
W. TROY HALL, Jr., Circuit Judge.
Findings of fact and conclusions of law, March 9, 1970: This case stems from three things —
1. A deed to the plaintiff which describes his property as so much of a described parcel of ground lying south of a described road;
2. The fact that there is no recorded deed, plat or otherwise to show the width of the road at the area in question;
*603. That the state road department at some uncertain time placed what is the usual, if not the official, state road marker at a point 50 feet distant from the center line of the road. The plaintiff contends that the actual boundary is 30 feet from the center line. The center line, the true (?) boundary, and the marker are shown on a map of survey, attached to the complaint, which was made in 1948. The suit was brought in January of 1967.
The complaint prayed for a mandatory injunction requiring the removal of the marker or requiring the defendant to condemn the 20 foot strip, and to judicially declare the location of the south line of the road. Obviously the last request must first be considered and determined.
The cause came before the court on motions of all parties for summary final judgment. Default judgment had been entered against the defendant Lake County for failure to file defenses so at this point the defendants are the state road department and the city of Leesburg.
The court is keenly aware of the advantages and dangers of deciding cases by summary judgment. The mere fact that both plaintiff and defendants filed such motions does not preclude the possibility of there being a genuine issue as to a material fact. All it means is that each party thinks his own undisputed position is conclusive and that disputed facts are not material. Consequently the court has examined the pleadings, affidavits, interrogatories and exhibits with great care in order to discover if there is actually any genuine issue as to any material fact.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit