Court of Appeals of Kentucky March 27, 1970 (Howard v. Ingram)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-03-1970

DAVIS, Commissioner.

The trial judge sustained a petition for habeas corpus and ordered appellant to release Joe Ingram from the reformatory at La Grange. The appellant contends that appellee should have proceeded by motion to vacate as prescribed by RCr 11.42, citing Ayers v. Davis, Ky., 377 S.W.2d 154, and Davis v. Wingo, Ky., 396 S.W.2d 53.

Ingram was convicted in the Fleming Circuit Court for violation of KRS 434.070(1) (“cold check”), and his punishment was fixed at confinement in the reformatory for one year. On his motion he was placed on probation. KRS 439.260. About a year after the order of probation, Ingram was brought before the Fleming Circuit Court, and his probation was revoked. KRS 439.-300.

When the Fleming Circuit Court revoked Ingram’s probation, it sentenced him to confinement in the reformatory for two years instead of one as had been fixed in the original judgment of conviction.

The record reflects, without dispute, that Ingram had already served more than thirteen months in the penitentiary when he instituted the habeas corpus proceedings. As we have said, the judge of the Oldham Circuit Court ordered Ingram’s release. We assume he is not in custody — he has filed no brief in this court.

In Hord v. Commonwealth, Ky., 450 S.W.2d 530 (decided February 13, 1970), we held that a circuit court is without authority to mete a greater sentence when revoking probation than the sentence which had been prescribed originally. Exactly the same situation is presented in the present case. The Fleming Circuit Court had no authority to sentence Ingram to confinement for two years in face of his previous sentence for only one, Ingram had fully served his one-year sentence when his petition for habeas corpus was brought. He was entitled to be released from custody forthwith on the face of the admitted record.

As observed in Richardson v. Howard, Ky., 448 S.W.2d 49, and Waddle v. Howard, Ky., 450 S.W.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.