Court of Appeals of Kentucky March 6, 1970 (Hagan v. Higgins)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-1970

CLAY, Commissioner.

We have before us two appeals from a judgment based on a jury verdict upholding the probate of a will and codicil by the Hardin County Court and upholding the orders of that court rejecting for probate seven other testamentary documents.

W. A. Miller died February 28, 1966. He had executed a typewritten will October 4, 1950, when his wife was alive, and a typewritten codicil dated March 3, 1960, after she died. These were duly probated in the Hardin County Court on March 21, 1966. The codicil left Miller’s estate to his two brothers and a sister. This codicil was challenged on appeal to the circuit court by some of the appellants, children of a deceased brother and sister.

*581Some time later appellant Hagan offered for probate seven different testamentary documents allegedly executed by the testator subsequent to the date of the codicil. These were all rejected for probate and appeals were taken to the circuit court. The court consolidated all the appeals and the cases were tried together. The principal issue was whether the later documents were forgeries. The jury was instructed to find the instrument dated October 4, 1950, and the codicil thereto dated March 3, 1960, to be the last will and testament of Miller unless they believed they were revoked by the execution of a subsequent valid will. As before mentioned, the jury found for those two writings originally accepted for probate.

The first appeal we will consider attacks only the above instruction on the ground that the evidence did not justify the court in deciding as a matter of law that the March 3, 1960, codicil was a valid will. It is argued that the court should have rejected this instrument as a matter of law or should have submitted the issue of its validity to the jury. It is contended that the physical appearance of this codicil was such as to indicate the existence of a subsequent codicil revoking it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.