Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee September 3, 1970 (Crumley v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-09-1970

lead-opinion

OPINION

WALKER, Presiding Judge.

From the dismissal of his postconviction petition after an evidentiary hearing, the petitioner, Jack Crumley, Jr., appeals to this court.

He alleged that his appointed counsel was ineffective. By amendment he charged that his convictions of arson on pleas of guilty were void because he had no counsel in juvenile proceedings under which his cases were certified to the criminal court.

After a full hearing, the trial judge filed a thorough finding of facts in which he found all of petitioner’s contentions without merit. We think his findings are fully supported by the proof. His appointed counsel represented him in a most capable and professional manner.

The trial judge found that the petitioner waived counsel in the juvenile proceedings. In this proceeding he did not deny that he said he did not want a lawyer. His father was present at the juvenile hearing, but the petitioner did not call him as a witness.

Although we think the trial judge’s findings are sustained by the proof, we point out that a voluntary plea of guilty waives the failure to appoint counsel in a juvenile court hearing.

In Shepard v. Henderson, Tenn.Cr.App., 449 S.W.2d 726, 734, we said:

“Moreover, under the authorities here-inabove cited concerning the legal effect and import of a voluntary plea of guilty, and there being no arguable question about the trial court’s jurisdiction of the person and subject matter in Owens’ original trial, all alleged prior defects in the proceedings against him, if any, including the alleged right to and denial of counsel in the juvenile court hearing, were waived by his voluntary guilty pleas to the indictments and he is now precluded from raising any such alleged prior unconstitutional infringement of his rights by collateral attack upon his conviction.”

In a case challenging the failure to appoint counsel in juvenile court for a 15-year-old defendant who later pled guilty, the Supreme Court of Missouri in Jefferson v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.