Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 18, 1970 (People v. Balt)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-1970

Order and judgment (one paper) entered October 27, 1969, adjudging defendant (Balt) guilty of contempt of court unanimously reversed, on the law, without costs and without disbursements; personal attachment order issued therewith, entered October 27, 1969, vacated, and proceeding brought under section 750 of the Judiciary Law, dismissed. The appeal is properly, entertained on the merits. (OPLR 5701, subd. 2, pars, [iv] [v]; Matter of Grand, Jury, County of Kings [Beardon], 278 App. Div. 206; People vi Diefendorf, 281 App. Div. 465, affd. 306 N. Y. 818.) The court directive to Balt on October 9, 1969, upon the application for a stay of two subpoenas! to appear before the Grand Jury, was not, as claimed, a definite and lawful mandate directing him to advise his alleged clients to appear before the Grand! Jury. As a direction that his “ clients will comply with the process as amended ” and that the court would “ entertain a contempt proceeding if there is any violation of that order”, the direction is eonstruable as meaning *933that the threatened contempt proceeding would be brought if the amended subpoena was not complied with. The mandate was also vague as to whether Balt was to simply convey the court’s direction (which he allegedly did) to his clients, or whether he was ordered to actually produce them in court at the appointed hour. “ The ‘ mandate alleged to be violated should be clearly expressed, and when applied to the act complained of it should appear, with reasonable certainty, that it had been violated.’ (Ketchum v. Edwards, 153 N. Y. 534, 539.) Where the terms of an order are vague and indefinite as to whether or not particular action by a party is required, then, of course, he may not be adjudged in criminal contempt for a willful failure to take such action.” (Matter of Sheridan v. Kennedy, 12 A D 2d 332, 334; Matter of Carlson v. Podeyn, 12 A D 2d 810; Matter of Landau, 230 App. Div. 308; Matter of Mitchell v. Sperling, 229 App. Div. 204.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.