Supreme Court of Pennsylvania March 20, 1970, Appeal, No. 244 (F. W. Wise Co. v. Beech Creek Railroad)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-03-1970
Opinion by
Mr. Justice Pomeroy,
Plaintiff-appellee (Wise) sued the three railroad company defendants, all part of The New York. Central System (herein collectively referred to as “the Railroad”) jointly for damages-for breach of an alleged contract to sell to Wise for the sum of $15,000 certain real estate owned by the Railroad in the Borough of Clearfield, Pennsylvania, and not needed for railroad purposes (“the property”). The defenses of the Raib road were that no contract had been entered into; that, if .there were a contract, it was made by agents, who had no authority to bind the Railroad; and that,• assuming an otherwise valid contract it did not meet the requirements of the Statute of Frauds. These inat: ters were left to the jury by the trial judge, who overruled the Railroad’s motions for compulsory nonsuit and for binding instructions. The jury returned a verdict for plaintiff in the amount of $23,500. The Railroad’s motion for a new trial was refused, and judg*391ment was entered on the verdict. This appeal followed. We affirm.
At the outset we are met with the problem of what questions are properly before us-on this appeal. The Statement of Questions Involved, as contained in-appellants’ brief, is reproduced -in the margin.1
Question No. (1) is apparently based on the-first-reason given in the motion for a new trial, viz., “The court erred in refusing to grant the Railroad’s motion for nonsuit at the conclusion of plaintiff’s- case.”' • We hold that the refusal of a motion for nonsuit is not invalid reason for a new trial in . this or any casé where-the defendant offers. testimony. A'defendants -right to request a nonsuit is based on his offering no evidence, and the court cannot. grant a nonsuit after the’introduction of evidence by the defendant. \ -Act Of-March 11, 1875, P. L. 6, §1, 12 P.S. §645; Highland Tank and Manufacturing Company v. Duerr, 423 Pa. 487, 225 A. 2d 83 (1966); Jordan v. Sun Life Assurance *392Company of Canada, 366 Pa.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit