Louisiana Court of Appeal September 15, 1970, Nos. 11480, 11530 (Rochon v. Reliance Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1970

WILLIAMS, Judge.

Plaintiff, Abraham Rochon, Jr., filed this suit alleging that he suffered injuries on November 18, 1968 while he was an inmate at the Caddo Parish Penal Farm operated by the Caddo Parish Police Jury and named its insurer, Reliance Insurance Company, as defendant. Plaintiff alleged he was required to work on a sugar cane grinding machine and that three fingers on his left hand had to be amputated due to an accident caused by the alleged negligence of representatives of defendant’s insured.

*37Defendant filed a motion for summary judgment rejecting the demands of plaintiff. The Police Jury intervened claiming immunity and opposing the motion for summary judgment. The trial court sustained defendant’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed plaintiff’s suit and the opposition of the intervenor. Plaintiff and intervenor have appealed from this judgment.

Defendant based its motion for summary judgment on the following reasons:

(a) Plaintiff alleged that at the time of the accident he was an inmate at the Caddo Parish Penal Farm.

(b) As shown by Endorsement No. 1 attached to and forming a part of the policy of liability insurance issued by Reliance Insurance Company to the Police Jury inmates are excluded from coverage under the policy.

The policy, No. GA-1-21-39-22, along with various sheets stapled together herein filed, is certified as an exact copy of the original. This certification was made by Pabody-Stoer Insurance Agency as authorized representatives of Reliance. One of the sheets in the certified copy is duplicated as follows: •

Plaintiff and intervenor claim that there is an “absence and insufficiency of reference providing great uncertainty as to whether the insured and the insurer” intended the attached “Endt. No. 1” (relating to asylums) to become part of the whole contract. Such reasoning has no siTbstance. The first clause on the attached sheet indicates the procedure followed when the sheet is issued concurrently with the policy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.