District Court, N.D. California March 13, 1970, No. 51906 (Love v. Fitzharris)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1970

ORDER GRANTING RELIEF BY WAY OF HABEAS CORPUS

WOLLENBERG, District Judge.

Petitioner, charged with possession of heroin for sale, was committed, prior to trial, for observation at the California Rehabilitation Center from which he escaped one month later. He was rearrested in November, 1965, and charged with a second violation of California Health and Safety Code § 11500.5. He again escaped, and when recaptured pleaded guilty to the second possession charge as well as to the escape charges which had been brought. On March 22, 1966, petitioner was given concurrent terms for these offenses. On July 22, he was given another, consecutive, sentence for the original heroin charge.

On August 3, 1966, petitioner received a “Notice of Legal Status” which set his minimum eligible parole date (“M.E. P.D.”) at three years and four months. This date was set by the Adult Authority which at that time deemed Penal Code § 30491 to control cases where prisoners were sentenced to two or more consecutive terms for violation of Health and Safety Code § 11500.5.2 On August *70325, however, the Adult Authority, on the advice of the Attorney General, changed its interpretation of P.C. § 3049 and H. & S. Code § 11500.5 in such a way that persons serving subsequent sentences under § 11500.5 could not be eligible for parole until they had served at least two and one-half years out of each of the sentences they had been given. This new interpretation of the relevant statutes, though promulgated after petitioner had been tried and convicted of both his violations of § 11500.5, was applied to him. Another “Notice of Legal Status” was sent to petitioner, informing him that his M.E.P.D. was now five years, rather than three years and four months, from the time he had begun serving his sentences. Petitioner argues persuasively that this retroactive application of the Adult Authority’s new interpretation of the relevant statutes violates the ex post facto principle.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.